Skip to content
colored royal icing

Enhance Sugar Cookies: 5 Color Tips

The past five years have seen Decorated Sugar Cookies rise in popularity, thanks to the influence of social media, a growing trend towards customization, and the increasing interest in home baking. Crafting visually striking cookies with harmonious color palettes has become essential for standing out amidst competition. Here, we'll explore five ways to enhance your sugar cookie color game:

1: Use Gel Colors

In recent years, gel color has become the go-to choice for decorators around the world. Its popularity stems from several key advantages over liquid food coloring. Firstly, gel color offers unparalleled vibrancy and intensity, ensuring that your cookie creations pop with color. Additionally, its concentrated pigment means that a little goes a long way, allowing for precise color control without compromising the icing's consistency. With gel color available in a vast array of shades, the creative possibilities are endless. 

My favorite go to gel colors are from

Use code cheerfulbaker to save 10% 

For black and red I recommend  Americolor gel color

2: Create Custom Shades

One of the key benefits of using gel colors in royal icing for decorating sugar cookies is the ease with which decorators can achieve custom shades by mixing different colors together. Unlike traditional liquid food coloring, which can sometimes result in unpredictable hues or require large quantities to reach desired tones, gel colors offer precise control over color intensity and consistency. By simply blending small amounts of gel colors, decorators can create a wide spectrum of custom shades, from subtle pastels to bold primaries, ensuring their sugar cookies are adorned with precisely the right colors to bring their designs to life.  Using a color wheel is a very helpful tool in creating custom colors. 

3: Prevent Color Bleeding

Preventing butter bleed and color bleed when using gel colors in sugar cookies is essential for achieving professional-looking results. Butter bleed occurs when the fat from the cookie dough seeps into the royal icing, creating unsightly grease spots. To minimize butter bleed, it's crucial to allow your cookies to cool completely before decorating them with royal icing. Additionally, ensure that your royal icing is thick enough to form a sturdy barrier against any grease from the cookie. As for color bleed, which happens when colors bleed into each other, especially when wet, using gel colors can significantly reduce this issue. Gel colors offer superior pigmentation and stability compared to liquid food coloring, allowing decorators to achieve vibrant colors without worrying about bleeding. To further prevent color bleed, consider allowing each color layer to dry completely before adding additional colors or using a technique called "wet-on-wet" where colors are added to icing while still wet to ensure they blend seamlessly. By following these tips, decorators can create sugar cookies with crisp, vibrant designs that are sure to impress.

4: Use a Color Pallet Generator

Coolors is a versatile color palette generator that's perfect for anyone looking to design eye-catching sugar cookies. Whether you're a seasoned decorator or just starting out, Coolors offers a wealth of inspiration and customization options. To choose the ideal color palette for your cookie designs, simply visit the Coolors website or download the app. Browse through thousands of beautiful color schemes, ranging from bold and vibrant to soft and pastel. Once you find a palette that catches your eye, you can tweak individual colors or generate new combinations until you achieve the perfect look. Whether you're planning a themed party or simply want to add a pop of color to your baking projects, Coolors makes it easy to create stunning sugar cookies that are sure to impress.

Coolors - The super fast color palettes generator!

5: Using Dye Free Pigments

Utilizing dye-free food coloring in royal icing can yield vibrant results while addressing concerns about artificial additives. When opting for dye-free alternatives, such as natural food colorings derived from ingredients like fruits, vegetables, or spices, decorators can achieve vivid hues without compromising on quality or taste. To maximize vibrancy, it's essential to select high-quality dye-free colorings that are concentrated and offer a wide range of shades. When incorporating dye-free food coloring into royal icing, start by adding small amounts and gradually increase until the desired intensity is achieved. Remember to mix the coloring thoroughly to ensure even distribution. While dye-free options may require slightly more experimentation to achieve desired colors, the vibrant and natural-looking results are well worth the effort. By embracing dye-free food coloring, decorators can create visually stunning sugar cookies that are not only beautiful but also free from artificial additives, appealing to those with dietary restrictions or preferences for natural ingredients.



Leave a comment

Error Name required.
Error Comment required.

Please note, comments must be approved before publishing. All fields are required.