Decorating cookies is such a fun and creative process, but if you’re new to it, you might run into a few frustrating mishaps. Whether it’s dealing with icing consistency issues, cookies that spread too much, or piping that looks a little wobbly, every beginner makes mistakes—it’s part of the learning process!
The good news? These icing mistakes and cookie decorating blunders are totally fixable with a few simple adjustments. In this post, I’ll walk you through the top 5 cookie decorating mistakes beginners make and exactly how to avoid them.
Mistake #1: Icing Consistency Issues
The Problem:
One of the most common icing mistakes beginners make is using the wrong icing consistency for the job. If your icing is too runny, it will flood over the edges of your cookies, take forever to dry, and might even bleed into other colors. If it’s too thick, it won’t settle smoothly, leaving behind lumpy, uneven designs.
How to Fix It: The Spoon Test
Getting the right icing consistency is one of the most important skills in cookie decorating, and the spoon test is an easy way to check if your icing is ready before you start decorating.
How to Do the Spoon Test:
-
Scoop up a spoonful of icing and let it drizzle back into the bowl.
-
Count how many seconds it takes for the icing to settle and smooth out completely.
- 15-20 seconds: Great for flooding large areas.
- 10-12 seconds: Perfect for detailed flooding and wet-on-wet designs.
- 8 seconds or less: Too runny! Add a bit of powdered sugar to thicken it.
- 20+ seconds: Too thick! Add a few drops of water to thin it out.
-
Adjust as needed—adding more powdered sugar for a thicker consistency or small drops of water to loosen it.
Getting your icing consistency right will instantly improve the look of your cookies and make decorating so much easier!
👉 Not sure where to start? My royal icing recipe is beginner-friendly and perfect for decorating cookies!
Mistake #2: Icing Bleeding or Cratering
The Problem:
Have you ever decorated a cookie and later noticed that the colors have bled into each other or that parts of the icing have sunk in, leaving little craters? This usually happens because of:
- High humidity
- Overly thin icing
- Improper drying techniques
How to Fix It:
✅ Use a fan or a dehydrator to speed up drying and prevent icing mistakes like color bleeding.
✅ Layer your icing properly—start with a thin base layer, let it dry, then add details on top.
✅ Avoid over-saturating colors—too much food coloring can weaken your icing and make bleeding more likely.
By controlling drying time and humidity, you can prevent these common icing mistakes and keep your designs looking sharp!
Mistake #3: Messy Piping & Uneven Outlines
The Problem:
Shaky hands, uneven lines, and outlines that don’t connect smoothly can make even the most beautifully designed cookies look messy. Beginners often struggle with:
- Unsteady hands while piping
- Inconsistent pressure on the piping bag
- Not having a clear guide for their design
How to Fix It:
✅ Practice pressure control—pressing too hard makes thick, blobby lines, while too little pressure results in broken, weak lines.
✅ Use a piping guide—one of the best ways to practice piping is to draw lines, shapes, and swirls on a piece of paper, then place the paper inside a plastic sleeve sheet protector. Use a piping bag filled with piping icing and trace over your designs. You can wipe it off and start again!
✅ Anchor your hand—rest your wrist on the table to steady your movements while piping.
Practicing these techniques will help you create clean, crisp lines and beautiful designs every time!
Mistake #4: Cookies Spreading Too Much While Baking
The Problem:
You roll out your dough, carefully cut out beautiful shapes, pop them in the oven, and… they come out looking like melted blobs. This happens when:
- The dough is too warm before baking.
- The recipe isn't designed for cut-out cookies.
- The cookies aren't baked long enough to set properly.
How to Fix It:
✅ Chill your dough for at least 30 minutes before baking—this helps cookies hold their shape.
✅ Use a tested sugar cookie recipe that’s designed for decorating.
✅ Make sure your cookies are fully baked—if cookies are underbaked, they will be too soft and more likely to warp or break when decorated.
The Maillard Reaction & Why It Matters
Baking cookies long enough allows the Maillard reaction to happen—this is the process where sugars and proteins react with heat to create that golden-brown color and develop flavor. If you underbake your cookies, they won’t hold up well to icing, and you’ll miss out on that delicious crisp texture.
For best results, bake until the edges are just slightly golden brown, then let them cool completely before decorating!
Mistake #5: Running Out of Time & Feeling Overwhelmed
The Problem:
Decorating cookies is time-consuming, and if you try to do everything in one day, you might end up frustrated and exhausted.
How to Fix It:
✅ Break the process into steps:
- Day 1: Bake your cookies.
- Day 2: Make icing and prep colors.
- Day 3: Decorate in stages.
✅ Plan ahead—if you’re decorating for an event, start a few days in advance.
By breaking it down, you’ll enjoy decorating without stress!
⭐ Want to make decorating even easier? My Cheerful Box subscription includes 6 large cutters, 3 mini cutters, a stencil, and an online decorating class so you can decorate cookies without the guesswork! Each month features a surprise seasonal or holiday theme, so you’ll always have fresh, fun designs to create. Check it out here!
FAQs About Icing Consistency & Common Royal Icing Mistakes
1. Why does my royal icing dry dull instead of shiny?
If your icing looks dull, it may have dried too slowly. Using a fan or a dehydrator can help speed up drying and give your icing a nice shine.
2. How do I fix royal icing that’s too runny?
If your icing is too thin, add powdered sugar a little at a time until it thickens.
3. How do I prevent craters in small icing details?
Try piping a thin base layer, letting it dry slightly, and then adding another layer of icing on top.
4. Why do my royal icing colors bleed into each other?
This is usually caused by humidity or oversaturated colors. Use a fan or dehydrator to help your icing dry faster and avoid overmixing food coloring.
Every decorator makes mistakes when they start out—but by avoiding these icing mistakes and perfecting your icing consistency, you’ll save time, reduce frustration, and create cookies that look as amazing as they taste!
Have a cookie decorating question? Drop it in the comments—I’d love to help!
